Are you tired of choosing between comfort and professionalism in your wardrobe? Collars and Co promises to solve this dilemma with their innovative dress collar polos that blend the structure of formal shirts with the comfort of athletic wear.
Founded in 2021 by entrepreneur Justin Baer, this brand gained massive attention after appearing on Shark Tank and securing deals with Mark Cuban and Peter Jones.
This comprehensive review examines everything you need to know about the brand, from product quality and pricing to customer satisfaction and real world performance.
Key Takeaways
- Innovative Design Philosophy: Collars and Co revolutionizes business casual wear by combining structured dress shirt collars with performance polo comfort. Their patented collar technology maintains its shape under blazers and sweaters, solving a common problem with traditional polos that lose structure throughout the day.
- Premium Materials and Construction: The brand uses four way stretch fabric blending polyester, viscose, and elastane for superior flexibility and comfort. Products feature moisture wicking properties, wrinkle resistance, and OEKO-TEX certified materials that require minimal maintenance while delivering professional appearance.
- Strong Value Proposition: Priced between $60 to $90, Collars and Co occupies the sweet spot between mass market and luxury brands. The combination of performance features, professional aesthetics, and durability often justifies the investment for modern professionals who value both style and functionality.
- Mixed Customer Feedback: While many customers praise the comfort and versatility, some users report sizing inconsistencies and concerns about the synthetic fabric feel. The brand shows a 1.17 out of 5 star rating on some review platforms, indicating significant quality control challenges that potential buyers should consider.
- Target Market Alignment: Ideal for hybrid workers, frequent travelers, and professionals who want to maintain a polished appearance without traditional dress shirt limitations. Less suitable for those who prefer 100% natural fibers or extremely relaxed fits.
The Story Behind Collars and Co: From Startup to Shark Tank Success
Collars and Co represents a fresh approach to solving age old menswear problems. The brand emerged from founder Justin Baer’s frustration with traditional business casual options that forced men to choose between looking professional and feeling comfortable. His innovative solution combined the sharp appearance of dress shirt collars with the ease and comfort of performance polos.
The company’s breakthrough moment came with their Shark Tank appearance, where they successfully pitched their concept to investors Mark Cuban and Peter Jones. This exposure led to a 300% surge in web traffic and doubled their sales, demonstrating what many call the “Shark Tank effect.” The investment and mentorship from these business moguls provided the capital and expertise needed to scale operations and expand their product line.
Since the Shark Tank deal, Collars and Co has grown exponentially, generating over $20 million in revenue within just two years of operation. The brand has expanded from a single dress collar polo to a comprehensive line of professional wear including performance dress shirts, tailored chinos, and Italian inspired layering pieces. This rapid growth demonstrates strong market demand for their innovative approach to modern menswear.
Top 5 Amazon Prime Day Deals (Don't Miss)
- RUGGED. RELIABLE. READY FOR ANYTHING: Climb the highest peak; Bike the long way home; The durable titanium design is our...
- USE YESTERDAY TO BEAT TODAY: Meet your biggest competition — you; Challenge yourself to perform at your peak on your next...
- SONY’S LIGHTEST WIRELESS NOISE CANCELING HEADBAND EVER: Weighing just 192g, our lightest overhead wireless headphones with...
- DUAL NOISE SENSOR TECHNOLOGY: Take noise canceling to the next level with Sony’s Integrated Processor V1, so you can fully...
- SOUND BY BOSE. We teamed up with Bose to bring you a high-fidelity audio experience defined by clarity of sound and depth of...
- SUPERIOR ACTIVE NOISE CANCELLING. Block out the world and dive into pure sound with next-level noise cancellation.
- BLUEAIR’S TOP-PERFORMING AIR PURIFIER LINE: Blue family’s new Pure Max series with our proprietary HEPASilent performance...
- LET’S CLEAR THE AIR QUIETER: Quiet Mark certified (23-53dB); Cleans up to 3,048 sqft space in 60 min,1,524sqft in 30min or...
- SINGLE SERVE COFFEE MAKER: Single serve coffee or espresso at the touch of a button. Innovative programs and features such as...
- COFFEE FOR EVERY OCCASION: Brew better coffee at home with Nespresso's single serve coffee maker. Drink your coffee bold,...
The company’s success story reflects broader changes in workplace dress codes and lifestyle preferences. As remote work and hybrid schedules become more common, professionals seek clothing that transitions seamlessly between home offices, client meetings, and social settings. Collars and Co positioned itself perfectly to meet this evolving demand.
Product Innovation: The Technology Behind the Dress Collar Polo
The heart of Collars and Co’s innovation lies in their patented collar technology that maintains structure and appearance throughout the day. Unlike traditional polos that often look casual or sloppy under blazers, their dress collar polos feature built in collar stays and reinforced construction that keeps the collar crisp and professional looking.
The fabric technology represents another key innovation. Their proprietary four way stretch blend combines polyester, viscose, and elastane to create material that moves with your body while maintaining its shape. This synthetic blend offers several advantages over traditional cotton dress shirts, including moisture wicking properties, faster drying times, and wrinkle resistance that eliminates the need for ironing.
OEKO-TEX certification ensures that all fabrics meet strict environmental and safety standards, addressing growing consumer concerns about textile production. The materials are also machine washable, making maintenance simple and cost effective compared to dry clean only dress shirts.
The collar designs include three main styles: English Spread, Cutaway, and Semi-Spread. Each option provides different levels of formality and works with various face shapes and personal preferences. The English Spread collar remains their most popular option, offering versatility for both business and casual settings.
Material Quality and Construction Standards
Collars and Co uses a carefully engineered fabric blend that prioritizes performance over traditional luxury. The combination of polyester, viscose, and elastane creates shirts that feel surprisingly soft while maintaining professional appearance. However, this synthetic composition has generated mixed reactions from customers who prefer natural fiber clothing.
The construction quality shows attention to detail with reinforced seams, quality stitching, and durable button attachments. Collar stays come integrated into the design, eliminating the common problem of losing removable stays. The shirts feature moisture wicking technology that helps regulate body temperature during long days or stressful meetings.
Durability tests from customer reviews indicate that the shirts maintain their appearance and comfort after multiple washes. The synthetic blend resists shrinking, fading, and wrinkle formation better than many cotton alternatives. However, some users report that the collar may soften over time with frequent washing, though this appears to be a minority experience.
Quality control has emerged as a concern based on customer feedback. Some buyers report receiving products with construction defects, inconsistent sizing, or color variations from online photos. These issues suggest that the company may be experiencing growing pains as they scale production to meet increasing demand.
Sizing and Fit Guide: Finding Your Perfect Match
Collars and Co offers sizes from Small to 4XL, accommodating a wide range of body types. The brand aims for a gently tailored silhouette that avoids both boxy traditional fits and overly slim modern cuts. However, achieving the right fit requires careful attention to their sizing charts and customer feedback.
Size consistency appears to be a challenge based on customer reviews. Many users recommend sizing up, particularly for those with broader shoulders or muscular builds. The athletic cut can feel restrictive for some body types, especially around the chest and shoulder areas. Conversely, some customers find their usual size fits perfectly, indicating possible inconsistencies in manufacturing.
The sleeve length tends to run slightly short for taller individuals, which can be problematic for layering under blazers or sweaters. The shirt length is designed for both tucked and untucked wear, though the specific proportions may not work equally well for all body types.
Customer feedback suggests that the fit works best for men with athletic or slim builds who prefer a more tailored appearance. Those who prefer relaxed or loose fitting clothing may find the performance cut too restrictive. The synthetic fabric blend does provide some stretch, but it cannot compensate for significant sizing errors.
Price Analysis: Value for Money Assessment
At $60 to $90 per shirt, Collars and Co positions itself in the premium casual wear segment. This pricing places them above mass market brands like Polo Ralph Lauren or Lacoste, but below luxury options like Brunello Cucinelli or Tom Ford. The question becomes whether the innovative features and construction justify this price point.
Compared to traditional dress shirts, the pricing appears competitive when factoring in the performance benefits. High quality dress shirts from brands like Brooks Brothers or Charles Tyrwhitt often cost similar amounts, but lack the comfort and easy care features of Collars and Co products. The elimination of dry cleaning costs and ironing time adds value for busy professionals.
The cost per wear calculation favors Collars and Co for professionals who need versatile pieces that work in multiple settings. A single dress collar polo can replace both casual polos and dress shirts in many situations, potentially reducing overall wardrobe costs. However, this value proposition only works if the quality and durability meet expectations.
Promotional pricing and sales can make the products more accessible. The company frequently offers discounts through email marketing and seasonal sales, sometimes reducing prices by 20-30%. First time buyers should consider waiting for these promotions to test the products at lower risk.
Customer Experience and Service Quality
Customer service quality appears inconsistent based on available reviews and feedback. While some customers report excellent support experiences with responsive communication and helpful solutions, others describe frustrating interactions with poor resolution outcomes. This inconsistency suggests that the company may be struggling to maintain service standards during rapid growth.
Shipping and delivery generally receive positive feedback, with most orders arriving within the promised timeframes. The packaging quality protects products during transit and creates a premium unboxing experience that reinforces the brand positioning. However, some customers report receiving wrong items or sizes, indicating potential fulfillment challenges.
The return policy offers 30 days for returns, which provides reasonable protection for sizing issues or quality concerns. However, the return process complexity and customer service responsiveness can make exchanges frustrating. Some customers report multiple attempts to resolve simple issues, suggesting inadequate staff training or system limitations.
Communication quality varies significantly, with some representatives providing helpful guidance while others appear to lack product knowledge or problem solving authority. This inconsistency undermines customer confidence and may contribute to negative review patterns observed on various platforms.
Real World Performance: How Products Actually Perform
Daily wear testing reveals that Collars and Co products generally deliver on their comfort promises. The four way stretch fabric allows for comfortable movement throughout long days, whether sitting at desks, traveling, or attending social events. The moisture wicking properties help maintain comfort during stressful situations or warm weather.
Professional appearance holds up well in business settings, with the structured collars maintaining their shape under blazers and sweaters. The shirts photograph well in video calls, an increasingly important consideration for remote and hybrid workers. The color retention remains strong after multiple washes, maintaining professional appearance over time.
Durability concerns emerge from extended use reports. While the shirts maintain their comfort and basic appearance, some users notice fabric pilling or collar softening after six months of regular wear. The synthetic blend handles frequent washing better than cotton, but may not achieve the longevity of premium natural fiber shirts.
Versatility testing confirms that the dress collar polos work well in multiple settings. They transition effectively from business casual offices to social events, making them valuable for professionals with varied schedules. However, they may not be appropriate for the most formal business environments that require traditional dress shirts.
Comparison with Competitors: Market Position Analysis
Mizzen+Main offers similar performance focused dress shirts with comparable pricing and features. Their products use different fabric blends but target the same professional customer base. Mizzen+Main has longer market presence and more established customer service systems, potentially offering more reliable experiences.
UNTUCKit focuses on shirts designed for untucked wear, appealing to similar casual professional aesthetics. Their pricing runs slightly lower, but they lack the innovative collar technology that sets Collars and Co apart. UNTUCKit also offers more retail locations for in person fitting and service.
Ministry of Supply emphasizes technical innovation in professional wear, using advanced materials and construction techniques. Their products often cost more than Collars and Co, but may offer superior performance and durability. They also provide more transparent information about fabric sourcing and manufacturing processes.
Traditional brands like Polo Ralph Lauren or Lacoste offer established quality and brand recognition at lower price points. However, they lack the performance features and innovative design elements that distinguish Collars and Co. Professionals seeking cutting edge functionality may find traditional options insufficient.
Common Complaints and Issues
Sizing inconsistency represents the most frequent customer complaint across multiple review platforms. Many buyers report that their usual size does not fit properly, leading to return hassles and frustration. This issue suggests quality control problems that could impact brand reputation and customer loyalty.
Customer service problems appear regularly in negative reviews, with customers reporting unresponsive support, delayed responses, and unhelpful resolution attempts. These service issues can transform minor problems into major customer satisfaction failures, contributing to low overall ratings on some platforms.
Quality control concerns include reports of construction defects, color variations, and premature wear. While these issues may affect only a small percentage of products, they indicate potential manufacturing oversight problems that could worsen as production scales increase.
Fabric preferences divide customers, with some loving the synthetic blend performance while others prefer natural fiber feel and breathability. This preference gap limits the brand’s appeal to certain customer segments and may require product line diversification to address different needs.
Pros and Cons Summary
Advantages of Collars and Co products include innovative collar design that maintains professional appearance, comfortable four way stretch fabric, easy care requirements, and versatile styling options. The shirts effectively bridge the gap between formal and casual wear, making them valuable for modern professional lifestyles.
Performance benefits like moisture wicking, wrinkle resistance, and machine washability provide practical advantages over traditional dress shirts. The elimination of ironing and dry cleaning saves time and money while maintaining professional appearance standards.
Disadvantages include pricing that may exceed budget conscious shoppers’ limits, synthetic fabric feel that some customers dislike, sizing inconsistencies that complicate online ordering, and customer service issues that can frustrate problem resolution efforts.
Quality control concerns and mixed customer reviews suggest that the brand may be experiencing growing pains that affect product consistency and customer satisfaction. These issues could impact long term brand reputation if not addressed effectively.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Collars and Co shirts worth the price?
The value depends on your priorities and lifestyle. For professionals who value comfort and easy maintenance, the price can be justified.
How do Collars and Co shirts fit compared to other brands?
They tend to run more fitted than traditional brands, with many customers recommending sizing up for comfort.
Do the collars really stay crisp all day?
Most customers report that the patented collar technology does maintain structure better than regular polos.
Can you wear these shirts without a blazer?
Yes, they work well both alone and layered under jackets or sweaters.
How long do Collars and Co shirts last?
Durability varies, but most customers report good performance for 6-12 months of regular wear.
Are the shirts suitable for sensitive skin?
The synthetic blend may irritate some sensitive skin types, though most customers find them comfortable.
What is the return policy?
Collars and Co offers a 30 day return policy, though some customers report challenges with the return process.
